Showing posts with label classical music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label classical music. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 30, 2026

BOOK REVIEW - "CLASSICAL MUSIC: THE 50 GREATEST COMPOSERS AND THEIR 1,000 GREATEST WORKS" BY PHIL G. GOULDING


 My favorite genres of music are Classical and Symphonic Rock. Do I consider myself an expert on who's the best? Not even close. I like what I like and will give what I don't like a couple of times. There are certain eras I prefer to others: Baroque isn't my cup of tea, I love a lot of the romantic era, and sometimes I think the principal instrument in 20th Century music is fingernails on the chalk board.

That being said, I picked up "Classical Music: The 50th Greatest Composers and Their 1,000 Greatest Works" by Phil Goulding, wondering how much disagreement we'll have. While there are disagreements, I find myself agreeing more.

Goulding started this book as a challenge by his wife At that point, I probably knew more than he did. His approach to ranking the artists was sound, using how many pages of music by the composers as a guide. 

He starts off with a few lists about the performers, including his ranking, the composer's century of birth, and their home country. He goes through his list with a short biography of the composer, focused on their compositions. He then provides a starter list (5 items), a top ten (as you'd expect, 10), and a Master's list. There are a couple where Goulding's Master's list is the same as the top ten; others have enough that he recommends a library.

You don't have to open the book to know his top 10: it's on the outside back cover. The top 10 is: 

  1. Johann Sebastian Bach
  2. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
  3. Ludwig van Beethoven
  4. Richard Wagner
  5. Franz Joseph Haydn
  6. Johannes Brahms
  7. Franz Schubert
  8. Robert Schumann
  9. George Frideric Handel
  10. Peter Ilyitch Tchaikovsky

Actually, I have few arguments. I wouldn't have Schumann on my list: I've tried listening to him on occassion and remain unimpressed compared to the others. Plus, with two of my three favorite composers ranked 11th and 12th - Mendelssohn and Dvorak respectively; Beethoven is my other favorite - Schumann would find him slipping to the teens on my list. Having read the book, I doubt I'd get much argument at that point: Goulding commented that if someone wanted to rearrange the order of the top 3, he'd see nothing wrong with that.

He ranks a pair of my favorites further down - Bruckner at 25 and Rimski-Korsakov at 42. Three others are missing from his list: Correlli, Franz Berwald, and Carl Phillip Emannuel Bach, but overall, I think his ranking is more objective while I won't at all claim my rankings are subjective. 

The book is concluded with a section on the orchestra and its instruments and arrangement and a 42 page discography.

If you are interested in learning more about classical music and its composers, I very hightly recommend this book. 


Tuesday, May 19, 2026

BOOK REVIEW - "THE ROUGH GUIDE TO CLASSICAL MUSIC: AN A-Z OF COMPOSERS, KEY WORKS, AND TOP RECORDINGS," EDITED BY JOE STAINES


I've heard of series like "Complete Idiot's" and "...for Dummies," but this is my first encounter with "Rough Guides." Joe Staines is listed as the editor of this book, and as co-authors with Jonathan Buckley, Phillip Clark, Andrew Dickson, Kate Hopkins, Stephen Johnson, Nick Kimberley, and Gavin Thomas.

This book gives you an introduction to many classical composers, identifies what is considered as their key works, and providing you with a list of recordings, making this a good guide if you want to enlarge your collection of classical music. 

Note I said this is "a good guide." Considering that three of my ten favorite symponies are not considered "key works" (i.e. the Lobesang and Reformation symphonies by Felix Mendelssohn, and the Singulaire Symphone of Franz Berwald), or that one composer I like is not mentioned (again, Berwald), I'm being fair when I call it "a good guide." After all, this is not meant to be exhaustive, and I've recently looked at another book where Berwald is again omitted from the list. 

I've read some reviews that are critical of this, but I do not agree with the criticisms. In spite of my disappointments, I think this book achieves its goals, and I would recommend it to someone who wants to learn more about classical music.

 


Tuesday, May 5, 2026

MEDIA REVIEW - CLASSICAL DESTINATIONS: AN ARMCHAIR GUIDE TO CLASSICAL MUSIC BY SIMON CALLOW


 

Classical Destinations: An Armchair Guide to Classical Music is available in three forms of media: Video (I believe it started as a PBS TV show), book, and music CD. I believe there are three seasons, and what I'm reviewing is season 1.

The format of the video and book is looking at various European cities and the classical composers that came from that area. The scenery is beautiful in both formats, and the CD is also enjoyable.

For those who want a nice overview like this, you'll enjoy it. It's pleasing to the eyes and informational. However, I did not enjoy it as much as I thought I would. Reasons?

  • This series focused more on the history and being a travelog than on the artists. I, on the other hand, wanted more focus on the composers.
  • Related to above, the book lacks an index. Thus, I had to dig through the book to find out about the artists I was most interested in.
  • Also, when I looked at the menu, I found the episode I most wanted to see on the first of two DVDs was the 7th of 7, dealing with Praugue and one of my favorite composers, Dvorak. But starting with the 2nd episode, the numbers are off, and instead of being on Prague, the 7th episode dealt with Venice, which was program #6 accordig to the guide.
None of those diminished from the quality of the product. If you saw the series on PBS, you'll enjoy having at least one of the formats. And the book would make a great coffee table book.


Saturday, March 21, 2026

BOOK REVIEW: "DVORAK'S PROPHECY, AND THE VEXED FATE OF BLACK CLASSICAL MUSIC" BY JOSEPH HOROWITZ


 

You might be familiar with Dvorak's Symphony "From The New World" (9th). With luck, you might even be aware that Jeanette Thurber established a National Conservatory to encourage a uniquely American classical music, other than parroting the German style. She considered Czech Antonin Dvorak and Finn Jean Sibelius (composer of Finlandia, which is the music for the hymn "Be Still My Soul"), both cultural nationalists, and selected Dvorak. Besides his "From the New World Symphony," he's best known for His Slovenik Dances, capturing the Bohemian sound of his homeland.

The composer created "From the New World" while in America from 1892-95. The debate is if the 2nd movement Largo was an African American gospel song given a classical arrangement or if Dvorak actually composed which had lyrics set to it. The third movement also had American influence - in this case, native American influence. In New York City, they loved the symphony because of the African American and Native American influence, and in Boston, they hated it for the same reason.

The focus on this book, though, was not on Dvorak's stay here but on the composer's thoughts about the future of classical music in America: "I am now satisfied that the future music of this country must be founded upon what are called the negro melodies. This must be the real foundation of any serious and original school of composition to be develped in the United States....These beautiful and varied themes are the product of the soil. They are American."(p. 7).

Horowitz observes that "Dvorak's prophecy" did not come to pass, and the rest of the book deals with the issue. The classical community did not, for the most part, welcome the African American influence, and musically the African Americans focused more on popular music, including jazz. The author deals with several influences on the culture, such as Frederick Douglas, Mark Twain, and Gershwin.

I found the theme and direction of this book interesting. For those who have an interest in the evolution of music styles, I would highly recommend this book.

Tuesday, February 7, 2023

BUCKET LISTS, MUSIC YOU CAN HEAR IN HEAVEN, AND OTHER SPECULATIONS

The Plains of Heaven by John Martin

 "Nacho, nacho man; I want to be a nacho man!"

Or is "mocha man" a more accurate description of me?

I'll confess: Seeing the Village People live would be on my bucket list, though it would be lower on the list. Hearing the Daniel Band and Idle Cure and Little River Band would all be higher on the list. So would hearing several classical compositions performed live, such as Mendelssohn's Reformation and Lobesang (Hymn of Praise) symphonies, Tchaikowski's Romeo and Juliet Fantasy Overture, Bruckner's Romantic Symphony and his Te Deum, Wagner's Flying Dutchman Overture, and of course my favorite symphony: Beethoven's 7th.

However, Russell Moore pointed out the philosophical problems with bucket lists for Christians. It presupposes that there are things on this earth that we'll miss out on if we don't see them before going to heaven. After all, isn't heaven so much more wonderful than anything here? If we missed something on earth, won't there be something even better in heaven? By the way, Moore did suggest that you visit the pyramids if you want to see them, because Scripture hints they may not be around during the Kingdom.

Now, I would love to see the Village People in heaven. Did you understand what I just wrote? First off, I'd like to see them (and everybody else) there; I don't want anybody going to the other place (though I do believe that other place exists and those who continue in their treasonous sin without turning to God for forgiveness through Christ's sufficient and completed sacrifice). That said, I'd also love to hear them perform, though I think the songs they'd do in concert in the Kingdom would not include the hits they're known for down here (I'll admit I'd love to hear "In The Navy" live).

I do know some of Little River Band are Christians, so I would not be surprised to get to hear them perform. I do know I can meet the members of Daniel Band and Idle Cure; the question is if there will be electric guitars in the kingdom, or if all the sets would be unplugged.

Of course, orchestras are already unplugged. I would not be surprised to see Mendelssohn direct the two symphonies mentioned above, and maybe have him do a duet with Charles Wesley on "Hark The Herald Angels Sing." Same is true with Bruckner conducting his "Te Deum" (Latin for "Thee, O God, We Praise).

But what about the others? I have no idea of Tchaikowski's faith. Wagner, however, inspired some of Hitler's beliefs. Beethoven on his death bed heard lightning and sat up shaking his fist at heaven. Would their music be played in the Kingdom? After all, even if they weren't among the saints, their music was at worst neutral and at best causing the listeners to praise God for allowing that music to be composed.

And so I go into territory that I believe the Bible is silent and there is no evidence on one side or the other except to be grounds for theological/philosophical discussion. I am blessed by the beauty of the works I mentioned. Same is true with the theme of Chariots of Fire. Due to the story of Eric Liddell, Christians love that song. But composer Vangelis dedicated that theme to the Greek god Pan.

The question? Would music composed by unbelievers but beloved for its beauty be performed in heaven? I mean, Mendelssohn or Bach would be able to conduct that music. Or will any memory of unsaved performers be destroyed, including their musical masterpieces?

What are you looking at me for? Do you think I have the answer? None any better than yours. I'd love to hear your thoughts.

Friday, July 23, 2021

REVIEW OF MENDELSSOHN IN BIRMINGHAM VOL. 3, PARTICULARLY LOBGESANG (SYMPHONY #2)


 

 Since I became a fan of classical music, my favorite composer as I grew older, from Beethoven to Dvorak to Bruckner to Berwald and now Mendelssohn. 

Some of you aren't into classical music, and may tell me you've never heard of Mendelssohn's music. I will kindly shake my head and ask you to turn in your hymnal to "Hark The Herald Angels Sing." You'll see Charles Wesley's name on the left for the words, and on the right you'll see the composer for the music identified as - you guessed it -  Mendelssohn. It makes me smile that the brother of John Wesley wrote words that would be set to music by a Reformed Messianic Jew who wasn't born when Charles was promoted to hymn writing in heaven.

Felix Mendelssohn by Eduard Magnus, 1846
Mendelssohn is typically assumed to have written five symphonies. His symphonies are numbered according to the order of their publication. For example, the Reformation symphony was the second one he wrote, but he put it on mothballs and it wasn't published until 20+ years after his death, and was numbered as his fifth. 

Above, I've pictured volume three of the collection "Mendelssohn in Birmingham". Mendelssohn visited Britain ten times during his short life (1809-1847). The first three volumes, which feature his symphonies (each also starts off with an overture), have a sketch done by Mendelssohn of Birmingham. (Each volume has a different ink color). Not only does it show that the composer was a talented artist, but it also showed some humor: Notice the large bird in the drawing? And in the forefront was the luggage of Mendelssohn and his two traveling companions.

The first two volumes feature four of his five symphonies, saving the longest for this volume. This symphony, designated as the second (though it was either his fourth or fifth that he wrote) is titled Lobgesang, which means hymn of praise. Like Beethoven's 9th, the symphony starts with three instrumental movements and then brings in a choir for the end. However, there are distinct differences. Beethoven's choral finale was a symphony movement with singing. The choir part of Lobgesang more resembles the Messiah than Beethoven, taking up the majority of the time of the symphony, and is usually divided into several parts. In fact, some modern music critics don't consider this a symphony but more of a sacred choral work. 

One reason I am looking at this rendition instead of just the symphony is that this includes the English translation of the lyrics, which Mendelssohn authorized (the original was in German). 

I'm not a professional music critic, but allow me to pretend to be one. The symphony starts off with horns playing a melody in a low key, echoed by the orchestra, not unlike a songleader singing a line from a song with the choir or congregation echoing that line back. There is no break between the minuet of the 2nd movement and the slow 3rd movement. The fourth starts with the orchestra playing the beginning of the theme from the first movement.

One interesting note is this was composed for a choir, a pair of sopranos, and a tenor. There is one short segment where the sopranos sing together.

When I listen to this symphony, the theme runs through my head, with the English words taken from Psalm 150: "Let all that has life and breath praise the Lord."

This volume starts off with an overture titled "Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage." I'll admit it's not my favorite Mendelssohn composition. It starts off very quietly, and sometimes if I don't put the volume on the stereo loud enough I miss the first couple of minutes of this overture.

Who is your favorite classical composer? What music helps you worship?