Conflict is an important part to an interesting story. A tale where everything goes right for the main character is basically BORING. What propels things is conflict. Maybe it might be a 100 year flood threatening a community, or an asteroid about to destroy the earth. But more often, it's an antagonist, with the villain being a typical form.
You probably realize it, but while all villains are antagonists, all antagonists aren't villains. In legal dramas, the opposing attorney and maybe the judge are effective antagonists, but they aren't bad... they're merely doing their job. For an example, attorney Mitch Taylor is the main protangonist in Randy Singer's second novel "Directed Verdict." After that story, Taylor becomes a prosecutor, and while keeping the characteristics you liked about him, he is a frustation to protagonists in later stories. Not at all a bad guy, but you're not rooting for him anymore. You don't want to see him hurt. You just want him to lose this trial.
But we find villains interesting, with it is an evil killer like Freddy Kruger or a cheater like Dick Dasterdly. In fact, as in the case of Batman or Dick Tracy, the hero is more bland while it's the villains that get the attention.
What are my preferences in dealing with villains? One thing is I like seeing villains survive the story, and maybe even be reformed. Sometimes, the bad guy needs to be taken out, but I am not always satisfied seeing the villain getting his case before the Ultimate Judge of the Thoughts and Intents of the Heart getting sped up (or in other words, the villain getting killed). In fact, I've been bothered in several James Bond movies where it seems more like the criminal gets murdered as opposed to executed, such as when he destroys Blofield's control tower using a solo passenger sub as a wrecking ball, with Blofeld inside the sub in "Diamonds Are Forever."
Another thing I like is when the villain has a sense of humor and seems to enjoy being bad. The Batman villains fall into that category. On the other end, I often find villains lack any redeeming value; if I didn't want a villain who's human, I would focus on sharks as being the foe. One movie like Jaws was fine, but that's the exception rather than the rule.
One more observation. Most villains fall into those who are in their right mind doing wrong things and those who are not in their right mind. The former are dangerous because their evil is well planned and thought out, the latter are dangerous because they're unpredictable. My preference is the former, but that's me. (I've never been a Joker fan.)
So now, let me give my list of favorite villains. They come from various sources: Novels, Movies, Comic Books, and TV. Some of these villains have appeared in different formats, and it's one form that puts him (or her - there's a couple of "ladies" in with the "gentlemen") on my list, and I'll point that out.
So are you ready for me to bring out the baddies? And I'll do this as a count down.
20. Jaws. No, not the movie. This Jaws was a henchman/assassin of the main villain (Karl Stromberg) in "The Spy Who Loved Me." Unlike most Bond bad guys, Jaws survives and returns working for Hugo Drax in "Moonraker." In the end, Jaws turns against Drax, and survives the adventure with his girl friend.
19. The Rhino, a Marvel supervillain who was introduced as a Spiderman foe and later faced the Hulk. In Hulk #102, we see him out of costume saying it was hard finding a job for someone who used to be the Rhino. He may have been meaning a job with a villain (and his old bosses rehired him with an acid proof costume), but my impression was that he was looking for a legitimate job, and I felt sorry for him. That put him high on my list. Looking at his bio, he later reforms.
18. Antonio Salieri, from "Amadeus," played by F. Murray Abraham. Won a well-deserved Oscar for this role.
17. The Gladiator, aka Melvin Potter, not to be confused with Kallark. Both Gladiators were Marvel characters. I am not familiar with the latter, whose main contact is with the X-Men. Potter appeared 11 years earlier, in '66, and was primarily a foe of Daredevil. He reformed, though he had some hiccups in his life since then.
16. Khan Noonian Singh, aka Khan. Yep, the superhuman villain introduced in the episode "Space Seed" of Star Trek, the Original Series, and returned in "Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan," played in both by Ricardo Montalban.
15. Flat Top Jones. I was introduced to him as one of Dick Tracy's best known villains, and in Chester Gould's comics, he also had a son (Flat Top Jr.), a daughter (Angeltop), a brother (Blow Top), and other relatives. But I'm focusing on his appearance in the Warren Beatty movie (1990), played by William Forsythe. One of my favorite scenes was when the main villain with his two henchmen Itchy and Flat Top tried to bribe the hero, who refused. So they rigged the boiler to blow up. As the bad trio left, Flat Top stopped, turned to Dick Tracy, and said, "You sure you don't want to change your mind?"
14. Fraer, villain/musician of Janalyn Voigt's "Tales of Faeraven." An example of a villain who had a sense of humor.
13. Muttley (snicker snicker), the henchman of Dick Dasterdly in Hanna Barbara's Wacky Races and the sequel (or prequel?) "Dasterdly and Muttley and Their Flying Machines." He actually was introduced as "Mugger" in the movie "Hey There, It's Yogi Bear," a little more menacing but exhibiting all the Muttley behavior.
12. Mad Madame Mim, from Disney's "The Sword and the Stone."
11. Javier Beck, from "Act of Valor", True Blue K-9 Unit Book 3, by Dana Mentink. I've read over 100 Love Inspired Suspense novels, and the villains are mostly evil people without a strong unique personality, with some who are just creepy pschotics. Beck stands out. His drug dealing was observed by the heroine of the novel, so his mission was to kill her to impress his higher-ups, and he seemed to have a ball in being a bad guy.
10. The Wicked Witch of the West. Cue in the evil music as she flies by on her broom, accompanied by flying monkeys. Do I need to tell you this is Margaret Hamilton's portrayal in 1939's "The Wizard of Oz?" I didn't think so.
9. The Catwoman. Of course, as a boy watching the Adam West/Burt Ward Batman series who also loved cats, it's logical for the character to be my favorite. Also of course, looking back at the three who had the role in the series and the multiple catwomen on the big screen, the one that rises to the top would be Julie Newmar.
8. The Mirror Master from 1990's Flash series, played by David Cassidy. Yep, Keith Partridge plays a villain, and I loved that portrayal. (Not the only atypical choice for a villain - Mark Hamil played the Jokeresque Trickster, which helped him get the role of being the Joker's voice in the cartoon series from the 90's.)
7. Marv from Home Alone, played by Daniel Stern. More fun than his boss, Harry (Joe Pesci)
6. Darth Vader (body of David Prowse, voice of James Earl Jones), Star Wars.
5. Scaramanga, played by Christopher Lee in "The Man With The Golden Gun." Another bad guy who seemed to be enjoying himself, including a duel with James Bond.
4. Blow Top Jones. Brother of Flat Top (see above). I got to see him in action in the 50th Anniversary story, where Dick Tracy and his unit ran into several of Tracy's old foes, including Blow Top. As you'd guess, Blow Top would lose his cool frequently, though only on trivial matters; he listened when it was a serious issue. And unlike his brother, his niece, and his nephew, Blow Top reformed.
3. Riff Raff, a thug of a badger and regular foe of Underdog.
2. Harry Mudd, played by Roger C. Carmel. I'm a Carmel fan, and enjoyed him play various bad guys, but the remembered role for me and probably most people was his two appearances in Star Trek, The Original Series. He also voiced Mudd in the cartoon series. Another villain who seems to be having the time of his life.
1. Riddle me this. Who do you think is the top of my favorite villains? If you say Frank Gorshin's portrayal of the Riddler on the Batman TV series, you'd be correct!
Would any of these be on your favorite villains list? Any you'd disagree with? How about ones that you're disappointed I didn't mention?